Pretending Is Half the Job
Why smoothing danger becomes your unpaid assignment
“Hey, can you take a quick look before this goes out?”
The draft is spotless—until you see the gloss. Harm framed as a trade-off. A back-room call recast as group consensus. So you flag it with a comment.
“Looks good—can you reword that so it still feels aligned?”
That isn’t feedback. That’s plausible deniability.
If you can turn danger into “something to consider,” you’ll be tapped again. Not to steer direction—just to sand the edges. You become the buffer between what an org does and the story it tells.
That’s pretending labor. You don’t lie. You package.
Causes harm → may raise questions.
This was a mistake → we might revisit.
You avoid burning people by serving truths lukewarm.
Soon those “quick gut check” pings arrive daily. You leave meetings unsure whether you changed anything or just made it easier to ignore.
Then you stop smoothing:
“I flagged this weeks ago. I’m not rephrasing it again.”
Instantly you’re “blunt,” “harder to work with.” Nothing else changed. You just quit absorbing what no one else will name.
I learned the script while I worked in product at a network of cancer hospitals, after flagging a flaw that could have negatively affected patients’ family members. As a member of the product team I thought it was my job to raise such issues. Privately, the CEO admonished me:
“Very often you are right. Your job here isn’t to always be right.”
Momentum beat accuracy—even where health was at stake. Clarity, unbuffered, was treated as a threat.
This isn’t dysfunction. It’s design.
Institutions don’t crave insight; they crave insulation. They lean on people already trained to self-filter—women, people of color, autistic professionals, first-gen staff—anyone who gets taught that how you speak matters more than what you say.
Survival made us translators. Refusal asks us to stop.
Refusal doesn’t need a speech. Sometimes it’s:
“If it lands hard, that’s the point.”
“I’m done softening this.”
“That’s not comms; that’s a decision.”
Not aggression—precision. It exposes the emotional labor the system was happy to keep invisible.
So when someone says, “You’ve changed,” they really mean:
You stopped shielding us from ourselves.
They’re right. And you’re done.
Further reading
Detection as Deviance — why early warnings get treated as noise
The Amnesia Engine — how critique is metabolized and selectively forgotten